Sign up to stay up to date on the Tenafly Home Values!

or Create your own market report
Active Properties
Address Beds Baths List Price DOM
72 Foster Rd 3 4 $1,095,000 1 day
125 Hudson Ave 6 7 $3,495,000 1 day
4 Marconi St 4 3 $1,395,000 2 days
2 Pleasant Ave 5 5 $1,720,000 2 days
157 Sussex Rd 4 5 $1,499,000 3 days
108 County Rd 3 2 $794,999 3 days
100 Heights Ln 4 5 $1,750,000 3 days
19 S Lyle Ave 3 2 $779,900 4 days
10 Day Ave 6 5 $2,795,000 4 days
1109 The Plz 1 1 $469,000 5 days
15 Colonial Rd 4 3 $1,180,000 8 days
704 Heights Ln 4 5 $2,495,000 24 days
224 Riveredge Rd 5 7 $2,285,000 12 days
16 N Brae Ct 5 5 $2,000,000 15 days
41 Downey Dr 4 4 $1,998,000 16 days
45 Oxford Dr 5 3 $2,599,000 19 days
180 Tekening Dr 5 6 $2,898,000 23 days
18 Oak St 3 2 $999,000 23 days
95 Magnolia Ave 7 6 $3,600,000 26 days
128 Westervelt Ave 4 6 $2,849,000 30 days
22 Elm St 3 2 $902,000 32 days
1310 The Plz Unit 1310 2 3 $788,000 32 days
43 Esmond Pl 3 2 $799,000 33 days
64 Day Ave 5 4 $1,700,000 33 days
35 Elm St 4 4 $1,460,000 33 days
40 Dean Dr 5 5 $2,000,000 38 days
175 W Clinton Ave 5 5 $2,800,000 40 days
161 Engle St 3 4 $1,175,000 45 days
3315 The Plz 2 2 $795,000 44 days
192 Stonehurst Dr 5 4 $2,315,000 53 days
270 E Clinton Ave 5 6 $2,150,000 54 days
40 Westervelt Ave 5 5 $2,795,000 55 days
76 Engle St 4 5 $1,750,000 64 days
240 E Clinton Ave 5 5 $2,190,000 65 days
120 Gordon Ave 5 3 $999,999 70 days
2315 The Plaza Plz 2 2 $798,000 73 days
1 Byrne Ln Unit 10 3 1 $588,000 88 days
211 Highwood Ave 7 10 $9,500,000 102 days
23 Benjamin Rd 6 6 $2,999,000 320 days
1314 The Plz 2 2 $675,000 199 days
90 Essex Dr 6 8 $7,800,000 228 days
10 Washington St N/A N/A $140,000 229 days
26 Highwood Ave N/A N/A $1,800,000 333 days
39 Highwood Ave N/A N/A $1,299,900 358 days
72 Piermont Rd N/A N/A $249,000 361 days
19 Huyler Ave N/A N/A $2,950,000 367 days
1 Conlon Ln N/A N/A $3,000,000 561 days
Average: 4.2 4.2 $2,023,697 88 days
Viewing 1 - 47 of 47
Viewing 1 - 47 of 47
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths List Price DOM
1209 The Plz 1 1 $459,000 30 days
26 Day Ave 4 3 $1,180,000 32 days
52 Bliss Ave 5 5 $2,288,000 33 days
97 Lawrence Pkwy 4 5 $1,998,000 37 days
11 George St 5 3 $1,100,000 40 days
4101 Piermont Unit 1203 1 1 $459,900 45 days
74 Davis Dr 6 4 $1,299,000 51 days
53 Columbus Dr 2 1 $624,000 51 days
171 Newcomb Rd 6 5 $2,700,000 58 days
130 Devriese Ct N/A N/A $2,200,000 75 days
8 Stanton Rd 6 8 $3,089,000 87 days
9 Woodland Park Dr 5 4 $1,890,000 89 days
260 Knickerbocker Rd 5 5 $1,300,000 94 days
1 S Park Dr 3 2 $1,399,000 106 days
30 Creston Ave 6 4 $2,300,000 107 days
60 Westervelt Ave N/A N/A $1,025,000 124 days
158 Oxford Dr 7 8 $7,388,000 260 days
118 Sunset Ln 3 4 $975,000 736 days
Average: 4.3 3.9 $1,870,772 114 days
Viewing 1 - 18 of 18
Viewing 1 - 18 of 18
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Sold Price DOM Sold Date
19 Harsen Rd 3 3 $949,999 106 days 9/18/26
111 Hudson Ave 5 5 $3,050,000 95 days 9/17/26
4102 Piermont Rd 2 3 $850,000 79 days 9/11/26
27 W Clinton Ave Unit 1E 1 1 $425,000 80 days 9/11/26
169 W Clinton Ave 3 3 $1,225,000 123 days 9/11/26
10 Marcotte Ln 5 3 $1,850,000 80 days 9/10/26
27 Suffolk Ln 4 3 $1,900,000 224 days 9/1/26
17 Wight Pl 6 5 $2,300,000 372 days 8/28/26
76 Hillside Ave 4 5 $1,700,000 66 days 8/21/26
1302 The Plaza, Unit 1302 2 3 $780,000 105 days 8/21/26
127 Westervelt Ave 4 3 $1,510,000 112 days 8/21/26
187 Hudson Ave 6 7 $4,775,000 130 days 8/21/26
55 Oxford Dr 6 9 $5,700,000 123 days 8/14/26
160 Magnolia Ave 4 4 $1,975,000 103 days 8/7/26
267 Hickory Ave 3 2 $999,000 106 days 8/7/26
1101 The Plz 2 2 $667,000 72 days 7/31/26
12 Cameron Rd 4 5 $1,775,000 56 days 7/30/26
109 Windsor Rd 4 4 $1,315,000 49 days 7/28/26
295 Tenafly Rd Unit I 2 1 $410,000 105 days 7/28/26
900 Heights Ln 4 5 $1,750,000 76 days 7/26/26
121 Lylewood Dr 6 5 $2,550,000 174 days 7/26/26
76 Magnolia Ave 7 3 $999,000 81 days 7/24/26
89 Surrey Ln 4 4 $1,806,000 97 days 7/22/26
61 Surrey Ln 4 4 $1,960,000 57 days 7/21/26
60 Oak Ave 4 3 $1,200,000 82 days 7/16/26
1112 The Plaza, Unit 1112 2 2 $730,000 90 days 7/15/26
7 Lindley Ave Unit B 4 4 $999,000 69 days 7/13/26
32 Grove St 2 1 $555,000 66 days 7/10/26
269 Engle St 5 4 $1,550,000 72 days 7/10/26
35 Lindley Ave 3 3 $885,000 42 days 7/9/26
18 Mission Way 4 3 $2,036,000 48 days 7/8/26
44 George St 6 5 $2,100,000 79 days 7/2/26
46 Park St 5 6 $4,150,000 72 days 7/1/26
21 Hastings Dr 7 10 $6,650,000 149 days 7/1/26
295 Tenafly Unit D 2 1 $460,000 93 days 6/30/26
364 W Clinton Ave 5 5 $1,750,000 113 days 6/30/26
168 Engle St 4 3 $1,200,000 84 days 6/29/26
89 Depeyster Ave 6 7 $3,525,000 65 days 6/26/26
14 Old Smith Rd 5 5 $3,150,000 86 days 6/26/26
90 Columbus Dr 5 5 $2,425,000 72 days 6/25/26
16 Norman Pl 6 5 $3,349,000 98 days 6/25/26
84 Depeyster Ave 6 7 $3,275,000 101 days 6/25/26
54 Windsor Rd 6 6 $2,875,000 271 days 6/24/26
126 Sussex Rd 4 4 $1,450,000 98 days 6/22/26
37 Oak St 4 4 $1,715,000 58 days 6/18/26
803 Heights Ln 3 5 $1,620,000 106 days 6/18/26
187 Buckingham Rd 7 8 $4,900,000 126 days 6/18/26
258 Highwood Ave 5 3 $1,780,000 82 days 6/16/26
75 Columbus Dr 4 3 $1,252,000 51 days 6/10/26
595 Knickerbocker Rd 4 4 $1,100,000 63 days 6/5/26
Average: 4.1 3.9 $1,861,925 89 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 67
Viewing 1 - 50 of 67
Advanced Search

board logoThe data relating to the real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program of the NJMLS. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than The CAROMIN Group are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. Some properties listed with the participating brokers do not appear on this website at the request of the seller. Listings of brokers that do not participate in Internet Data Exchange do not appear on this website.
All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Last date updated: .
Source: New Jersey Multiple Listing Service, Inc.
“2026 New Jersey Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.”